When it comes to choosing a garage door, homeowners often face a crucial decision: should they opt for an automatic garage door or stick with a traditional manual one? Both types have their own advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice depends on factors like budget, convenience, maintenance, and security. In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between automatic and manual garage doors to help you determine which one suits your needs best.
In this guide topics we will cover include:
- What are Automatic Garage Doors?
- What are the Pro’s and Con’s of Automatic Garage Doors?
- What are Your Options for an Automatic Door?
- What are Manual Garage Doors?
- What are the Pro’s and Con’s of Manual Garage Doors?
- Your Best Option Based on Lifestyle Needs
- Factors to Consider When Choosing Your Door
- Top Garage Door Brands You Might Consider
Understanding Automatic Garage Doors – Everything You Need to Know
Before you make your choice, it’s firstly important to understand what constitutes and automatic or a manual garage door. Automatic garage doors are usually equipped with an electric garage door opener (our door opener buying guide covers all of the main types, as there are many!) of some sort. Having an automatic door is an increasingly popular choice due to their ease, modern aesthetics, features and also the security benefits they offer.
Lets start by looking at the pro’s of automatic garage doors so you can make a true comparison with the manual options.
Pros of Automatic Garage Doors
There are four key benefits to having an automatic garage door in your home. These include:
Benefit 1: Convenience and Ease of Use
With an automatic opener, you can open your garage door with a remote control, wall-mounted switch, or even a smartphone app in some modern models – Liftmaster garage door openers such as the Liftmaster 86350 and 85870 models are good examples of chain drive options available to buy. This means you can open the garage door from the car, inside the house or even away from home.
In addition, automatic doors are absolutely ideal for people with mobility issues or those who don’t want to struggle with manually lifting a heavy door.
Benefit 2: Enhanced Security
Many automatic garage doors come with rolling code technology, which changes the access code each time the door is used, preventing unauthorized entry. See our guide on how to improve garage door security. Smart garage door openers allow remote monitoring and control, adding an extra layer of security, which is critical in today’s world of theft and burglary.
Benefit 3: Weather Protection
You don’t need to step out of your car in bad weather to open the garage, making it a more comfortable option during rain, snow, or extreme temperatures.
Benefit 4: Added Features
Many models of automatic garage door offer built-in lighting, battery backup systems, and integration with home automation systems. Some high-end automatic garage doors even include motion sensors, timers, and smart locks for added convenience our opener buying guide lists all features you can consider.
However, there are negatives to having an automatic garage door, which are explored next in the guide. Please consider these before you make your choice.
Cons of Automatic Garage Doors
There are really 3 main “negatives” you need to consider if you’re having an automatic garage door system installed at home:
Negative 1: Higher Up-Front Cost
Automatic garage doors are well known to be more expensive than manual ones due to the motorized opener, installation complexity, and additional features. In addition to the up-front cost, overall maintenance costs are higher since parts like the motor, sensors, and remote system may require repairs over time – these tasks and their associated costs are mostly covered in our breakdown of winter garage door maintenance tasks for openers.
When comparing the costs of manual versus automatic doors in the United States, prices can vary significantly based on factors such as door type, materials, size, and additional features. Here’s a breakdown of average costs:
Manual Doors:
Manual garage doors generally range from $750 to $6,325, with an average cost of $2,743. The price depends on factors like door type, material, and size.
Automatic Doors:
- Automatic Door Openers: The cost of automatic door openers varies based on the type
- Swing Door Openers: These are typically the most affordable option, ranging from $350 to $715.
- Sliding Door Openers: These cost more than swing door openers, typically ranging from $2,000 to $10,000.
- Automatic Garage Door Openers: Smart garage door openers with features like smartphone control and battery backup can range from $395 to $600.
Installation Costs:
- Manual Doors: Installation costs for manual doors vary depending on the door type and region but generally range from $200 to $600.
- Automatic Doors: Professional installation is typically recommended for automatic doors due to their complexity. Installation costs can range from $600 to $1,000 per opener.
Negative 2: Reliable Operation is Dependency on Power
If there’s a power outage and you don’t have a battery backup, you may not be able to operate your garage door. This is why a battery backup of some kind is an essential accessory item you have with any automatic garage door. Our guide on battery backups covers everything you need to know; including how they work, how much they cost and much more.
In the absence of a battery backup, some homeowners will install manual release mechanisms, but they require effort to use and if an automated system is something you have due to physical disabilities or weaknesses then you may find a manual release too challenging to use.
Negative 3: More Maintenance Required
As if we don’t have enough to do around the house already, automatic doors have more moving parts and electronics, increasing the likelihood of malfunctions and maintenance needs. Periodic servicing is necessary to keep the motor and sensors in good working condition. We cover the required tasks in our downloadable winter maintenance checklist.
Options for Automatic Garage Doors
Automatic garage doors come in a variety of styles and functionalities to fit different homeowner needs. Here are some of the most popular types – these are covered in more detail on our Garage Door Types guide:
Sectional Garage Doors
- Consist of panel sections connected with hinges that open vertically and slide along a track.
- Ideal for maximizing space and providing strong insulation.
Roller Garage Doors
- Made of narrow slats that roll up into a compact box above the garage opening.
- Great for small garages and homes that need enhanced security.
Side-Hinged Garage Doors
- Open like traditional doors with side hinges.
- Suitable for those who want a more classic or carriage-house look.
Up-and-Over Garage Doors
- Swing outwards and then up into the garage ceiling space.
- Often more affordable but require clearance space in front of the garage.
Smart Garage Doors
- Integrated with WiFi-enabled openers that allow control through smartphone apps.
- Provide real-time alerts, voice control (via Alexa or Google Assistant), and scheduling options.
Choosing the right type of automatic garage door depends on factors such as available space, security needs, and personal style preferences.
Understanding Manual Garage Doors – Everything You Need to Know
Manual garage doors require physical effort to open and close. They don’t rely on an electric motor, making them a simpler and more budget-friendly choice.
Pros of Manual Garage Doors
We believe there are 4 main benefits to owning a manual garage door over an automatic system. These include:
Benefit 1: Affordability
One of the main benefits of manual doors over automatic ones is that manual garage doors are significantly cheaper than automatic ones, making them a great choice for budget-conscious homeowners. Our costing breakdown above gives you a good idea of what the price difference is. It’s not just the product price which is cheaper though, there are lower installation costs with manual doors since they don’t require motorized openers or electrical work. You can expect to pay almost x 2 in supply and installation costs with an automatic option.
Benefit 2: Lower Maintenance Needs
In general, this type of door will come with lower maintenance costs overall. The main reason for this is that with fewer components which can fail, manual garage doors require less maintenance. With a manual system, there are no worries about motor breakdowns, sensor malfunctions, or power outages affecting usability.
Benefit 3: Durability and Reliability
Manual doors often last longer because they have fewer moving parts that can wear out over time. They are less prone to technical failures, making them a dependable option.
Benefit 4: No Power Dependency
Since they operate without electricity, manual doors work regardless of power outages. This can be advantageous in areas prone to storms or unreliable electrical service. In addition to this, they are not dependent upon technology either, so if your smart phone doesn’t work or the app becomes out of date then a manual system will never fail.
Cons of Manual Garage Doors
There are three main “negatives” to think about when considering a manual garage door. These include:
Negative 1: Less Convenient
Opening and closing a manual garage door requires physical effort, which can be a hassle, especially in bad weather. Opening a door manually is also not ideal for individuals with mobility issues or those who frequently use their garage.
Negative 2: Limited Security Features
Manual garage doors don’t have rolling code technology or smart security integrations (learn more about rolling code technology in our security guide). If they aren’t properly locked, they can be easier to break into compared to automatic doors with advanced locking mechanisms.
Negative 3: Lack of Advanced Features
Unlike automatic doors, manual ones don’t have built-in lighting, remote access, or smart home integration. Homeowners looking for convenience and modern features may find manual doors lacking overall.
Comparison Table: Automatic vs. Manual Garage Doors
For a quick comparison, we have compiled a table for you to refer to below. Hopefully, this will help you make your decision more easily:
| Feature | Automatic Garage Doors | Manual Garage Doors |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Higher initial and maintenance costs | More affordable with lower maintenance |
| Convenience | Operated via remote, smartphone, or keypad | Requires physical effort to open/close |
| Security | Advanced security features, rolling codes | Basic locking mechanisms, less secure |
| Maintenance | Regular servicing required | Low maintenance needs |
| Power Dependency | Requires electricity or battery backup | No power required |
| Weather Protection | Operable from inside vehicle | Requires stepping outside in all weather conditions |
Your Personal Circumstances – The Best Options Based on Your Lifestyle Needs
Choosing between an automatic and manual garage door depends largely on your lifestyle, which does incorporate the benefits and negatives discussed above. However, we’ve tried to compile the best options available to you, depending on the most common individual needs. Here are some recommendations:
- Best for Busy Families: Automatic garage doors provide convenience, allowing easy access for multiple family members.
- Best for Security-Conscious Homeowners: An automatic garage door with smart features offers better protection against break-ins.
- Best for Budget-Conscious Homeowners: A manual garage door is a cost-effective option with minimal upkeep.
- Best for Elderly or Mobility-Limited Individuals: Automatic doors eliminate the need for physical effort.
- Best for Detached or Seldom-Used Garages: If your garage isn’t frequently accessed, a manual door may be sufficient.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Automatic and Manual Garage Doors
Several factors need to be considered when choosing between manual and automatic garage doors. There are 5 in total, these include:
1. Budget
- If you have a limited budget, a manual garage door is the more cost-effective option.
- However, if you can afford a long-term investment, an automatic door offers more convenience and security.
2. Frequency of Use
- If you use your garage multiple times a day, an automatic door is a more practical choice.
- For garages that are rarely accessed, a manual door may be sufficient.
3. Security Needs
- Homeowners who prioritize security should opt for an automatic garage door with smart locking mechanisms.
- If security is not a major concern, a manual door with a sturdy lock can still offer reasonable protection.
4. Maintenance Preferences
- Those who prefer a low-maintenance option may find a manual garage door more appealing.
- If you’re willing to perform occasional maintenance and enjoy the added features, an automatic door is worth considering.
5. Climate and Weather Conditions
- If you live in an area with extreme weather conditions, an automatic garage door allows you to operate it without stepping outside.
- In milder climates, a manual garage door might be a sufficient and budget-friendly option.
What Brands Should You Consider in Your Choice?
Here are some leading brands known for high-quality garage doors:
| Brand | Features | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Clopay | Wide range of materials, energy-efficient insulation | Homeowners looking for variety and durability |
| Amarr | High safety features, wind-resistant options | Homes in extreme weather conditions |
| Wayne Dalton | Stylish designs, multiple custom options | Homeowners who prioritize aesthetics |
| Chamberlain | Advanced smart garage door openers | Tech-savvy homeowners wanting smart integration |
| LiftMaster | High-end security features, durable motor systems | Homeowners needing extra security and reliability |
These brands offer a mix of affordability, innovation, and security, catering to different needs and budgets.
Final Verdict: Which Garage Door is Right for You?
The choice between an automatic and manual garage door depends on your lifestyle, budget, and personal preferences.
Regardless of your choice, investing in a high-quality garage door that suits your needs will enhance the functionality, security, and aesthetic appeal of your home. Consider consulting with a professional garage door installer to explore the best options available for your specific requirements.
