C.H.I. and The Overhead Garage Door Corporation are well-respected manufacturers of residential garage doors, and both make garage doors in a variety of architectural styles, materials, and price ranges.
Both companies make high-quality steel doors in various cost tiers. These include steel doors at the low end of the price range, mid-priced doors with a choice of materials, windows, and insulation, and high-end, premium doors with numerous options and finishes.
Below you’ll find reviews of both manufacturers comparing materials, features, styles, and costs so you can find a garage door that will compliment your home’s architectural style and provide curb appeal at a price that works with your budget. Let’s get started with this garage door brand comparison.
History of the Brands
C.H.I. and Overhead Door began manufacturing residential garage doors over 40 years ago and is known for making quality doors and for providing exceptional customer service. C.H.I is headquartered in Arthur, Illinois.
The Overhead Garage Door Corporation, located in Dallas, Texas, was founded by C.G. Johnson, who invented the overhead garage door in 1921 and the electric garage door in 1926.
The Overhead Garage Door Corporation is currently the leading manufacturer of integrated systems for commercial, industrial, and residential garage doors.
The Overhead Garage Door vs C.H.I. – Your Product Options
Overhead Door makes garage doors in steel, steel with a vinyl or fiberglass exterior, wood, and aluminum and glass. Overhead Door also makes an aluminum rolling shutter door that can be used to provide privacy into a driveway from the street.
C.H.I. manufactures steel, wood, fiberglass, and aluminum and glass garage doors.
|Comparison of C.H.I vs Overhead Door Garage Doors By Style|
|C.H.I.||The Overhead Door|
|Planks, Sterling, Skyline Flush, Shoreline, Overlay Carriage House, Raised Panel, Stamped Carriage House, Stamper Shaker, Recessed Panel||Traditional Steel, Thermacore, Courtyard, Carriage House|
|Construction||1, 2, 3, 4-Layers||1, 2, 3, 4-Layers|
|R-Values||0 to 18.03||0 to 17.5|
|Steel with Vinyl Exterior|
|Steel with Fiberglass Exterior|
|Aluminum and Glass|
|Full-View Aluminum||Modern Aluminum, Envy, Allura Shutter|
|Price Range||$3,500-$6,500||$3,200-$6,500 +|
|Overlay Carriage House||Traditional Wood, Signature Carriage Wood|
|Styles||Carriage House||Traditional, Carriage House|
|Construction||4-Layer||2 or 3-Layer|
|R-Values||10.29 or 18.03||0 to 4.75|
Both companies make garage doors in a variety of architectural styles including Carriage House, Traditional, Modern, and Ultra-Modern.
An insulated garage door has many benefits over a standard. Overhead Door and C.H.I. both use polystyrene and polyurethane insulation and both companies offer a choice of insulation thickness. The polyurethane insulation is typically foamed-in-place into the door to create gap-free, high-quality, thermal protection.
Insulation material, as well as insulation thickness will vary by garage door profile.
Residential garage doors are made in layers with 1-layer doors consisting of only the material, such as steel or wood. A 2-layer door includes the primary material plus a layer of insulation. With a 2-layer door, the insulation is typically backed with a vinyl material. A 3-layer door will include the exterior layer like steel or fiberglass, the layer of insulation, and an interior layer of steel.
4 and 5-layer doors feature one of 2 layers of trim over the steel exterior layer. The trim layers are usually made of a composite material and are used to create the look of real wood cladding with rail and stile trim.
The Overlay Carriage House profile by C.H.I. is a 4-layer door featuring a layer of composite overlay trim. The Courtyard profile by Overhead Door includes a 4th layer of composite wood-grain textured trim.
C.H.I. garage doors finished with the Accents Woodtone option create the appearance of a real wood door through a three-step process. The process includes selecting premium lumber for a texture and color template, scanning the wood with high-resolution equipment to capture a non-repeating grain pattern, and applying the finish to the door, section by section. The finishes include Walnut, Driftwood, Mahogany, Cedar, Dark, Natural, and Carbon Oak. The process uses a UV topcoat to provide long-lasting protection.
Many of the CH.I. doors are also available with custom colors. Choose from over 180 RAL powder coated colors. View the color chart at the link below:
The Overhead Door Company also offers garage doors with wood-grain texture and finishes. The finish colors include Weathered Gray, Walnut, Golden Oak, Mahogany, and Cherry.
C.H. I. vs The Overhead Door Garage Door Costs
The prices quoted are based on a single, standard, garage door. Prices can vary greatly due to the number of layers and insulation included in the door construction. The style of windows, the type of glass, hardware, and finish selected can also affect the price.
C.H.I. offers a steel panel door, without windows or insulation for about $1,000, a fiberglass 3-layer door for about $4,000, and premium doors like wood or aluminum and glass for $6,000 or more.
Overhead Door prices start at about $800 for a steel garage door without windows or insulation. The cost of a steel door with a fiberglass exterior is about $4,000, aluminum and glass door costs around $6,500, and a premium wood door starts at about $3,000.
Both manufacturers offer a good variety of garage doors in the mid-level price range available with door panel, window, and insulation choices.
|Comparison C.H.I. vs Overhead Door Garage Doors by Price|
|Raised Panel||Traditional||Steel||1, 2, or 3||3.56 to 17.19||$1,000-$3,500||Budget-Mid-Range|
|Skyline Flush||Modern||Steel||1, 2, or 3||0 or 17.54||$1,200-$4,500||Budget-Mid-Range|
|Stamped Carriage House||Carriage House||Steel||1, 2, or 3||7.94 to 16.55||$1,200-$3,500||Budget-Mid-Range|
|Stamped Shaker||Traditional||Steel||1, 2, or 3||7.94 to 16.55||$1,200-$3,500||Budget-Mid-Range|
|Planks||Modern||Steel||3||10.29 or 17.54||$1,500-$3,000||Mid-Range|
|Fiberglass||Traditional||Fiberglass with Steel Back||3||16.95||$2,500-$4,500||Premium|
|Overlay Carriage House||Carriage House||Steel, Wood, Fiberglass||4||10.29 to 18.03||$2,800-$5,000||Premium|
|Full-View Aluminum||Modern||Aluminum and Glass||1||NA||$3,500-$6,500||Premium|
|The Overhead Door|
|Traditional Steel||Traditional||Steel||1, 2, or 3||0 to 9.8||$800-$2,500||Budget|
|Thermacore||Trad., Carriage, Modern||Steel||3||9.31 to 17.5||$1,700-$3,500||Mid-Range|
|Courtyard||Carriage House||Steel||4||9.3 or 12.76||$2,300-$3,500||Mid-Range|
|Carriage House||Carriage House||Steel||3||10||$2,000-$3,500||Mid-Range|
|Durafirm||Traditional||Steel with Vinyl Ext.||3||11.75||$2,000-$3,500||Mid-Range|
|Impression||Traditional or Modern||Steel with Fiberglass Ext.||3||7.6||$3,000-$4,500||Premium|
|Signature Carriage Wood||Carriage House||Wood||1 or 2||0 or 4.75||$3,000 +||Premium|
|Modern Aluminum||Modern||Aluminum and Glass||1||NA||$3,200-$6,000||Premium|
|Envy||Ultra-Modern||Aluminum and Glass||1||NA||$4,500-$6,500||Premium|
|Allura Rolling Shutter||Modern||Aluminum||1||NA||$4,500 +||Premium|
C.H.I. vs The Overhead Garage Door Collections
C.H.I. groups their doors by collection with a choice of architectural styles or profiles offered within each collection. For instance, the Carriage Collection consists of Shoreline and Overlay Carriage House and features 2 distinct profiles with door panel choices for each profile. Overall, C.H.I. features 11 profiles.
The Overhead Door also features 11 collections with each collection including only one profile in a specific architectural style with each profile offering a variety of door panel designs in that particular style.
The Overhead Door vs C.H.I. Garage Door Reviews
In the reviews below, we group the doors by architectural style and provide all of the details including material, construction, the choice of options, and available finishes.
Carriage House Style Garage Doors
The Overlay Carriage House door profile is available in steel, fiberglass, and wood. The steel and fiberglass doors are both made with the appearance of wood and include an overlay. The wood door includes a wood overlay in either red cedar or mahogany. All of the doors include a steel interior for strength and a choice of 2 ½” or 2 ¾” of polystyrene insulation. Choose from 24 door panel designs, over 20 window options, and a variety of decorative hardware. Prices range from about $2,800 to $5,000.
C.H.I.’s other carriage house style doors include Shoreline and Stamped Carriage House. The Shoreline features the appearance and texture of real wood in a 3-layer steel door insulated with polyurethane. Choose from 24 door panel designs, over 20 window and 4 decorative hardware options. Prices for Shoreline range from $2,000 to $3,500.
Stamped Carriage House features a deeply embossed, wood-grain textured, steel door in a short or long panel door design, and in 1, 2, or 3-layer construction. There are 9 standard color options plus 7 wood-tone finishes including Walnut, Driftwood, Cedar, and Oak, as well as, window and decorative hardware options, Stamped Carriage House is affordably priced at $1,200 – $2,800.
The Overhead Door Company
Overhead Door’s carriage house door profiles include Courtyard, Carriage House, Signature Carriage Wood, and Thermacore. The Courtyard is a 3-layer, polyurethane insulated, steel door with a 4th layer of composite trim molded to create the appearance of wood. This profile is available in 35 door panel designs, 6 window options, decorative hardware, and 9 standard colors. Doors can be painted in solid or in a two-tone style. Prices range from $2,300 to $3,500.
The Carriage House profile is made of steel and includes all of the features and options as the Courtyard but without the trim overlay. This door also offers finish options that provide the look of stained wood including Walnut, Mahogany, and Red Oak with prices between $2,000 and $3,500.
Thermacore is a 3-layer steel garage door insulated with a continuous layer of foamed-in-place polyurethane and provides R-Values of up to 17.5 depending on the thickness of insulation selected. There are 6 door panel designs, with 3 of them specific to the carriage house style, over 30 window options, and 12 standard colors and wood-grain finishes. Prices range from $1,700 to $3,500.
Signature Carriage is an all-wood door made to create the look of a swing-out carriage house garage door. The three profiles are Parson, Ponderosa, and Villa Madre. Each profile includes door panel choices, window, and decorative hardware options, and is available in a variety of stain or paint-grade woods including Mahogany, Red Cedar, smooth or rough-sawn plywood, and Knotty Cedar. Pricing starts at about $3,000.
Traditional Style Garage Doors
C.H.I. offers 3 traditional style steel door profiles – Raised Panel, Stamper Shaker, and Recessed Panel. These are all 1, 2, and 3-layer doors, with or without insulation. Each profile is available in a variety of door panel designs, over 30 window options, standard colors, wood-tone finishes, and custom colors. Prices range from $1,200 to $2,800.
C.H.I. also makes a traditional style garage door under the Fiberglass profile. The door features a steel interior, polyurethane insulation, and an exterior constructed from molded fiberglass, providing an R-Value of 16.95. The door is available in 5 door panel designs, including 2 with arches, creating the look of carved wood, and a variety of window options. Choose from standard colors, wood-tone finishes, or unfinished so it can be painted in your desired color. Priced at $2,500 to $4,500.
The Overhead Door
The Overhead Door offers 5 garage door profiles with traditional styling. The Traditional Steel profile is one of The Overhead Door’s more affordable steel garage doors and is available in 1, 2, or 3 layers, 5 door panel designs, over 30 window options, and standard, plus custom colors. Prices range from $800 to $2,500.
The Thermacore profile, reviewed under Carriage House Garage Doors, is also offered in several traditional style door panel designs. Durafirm is another traditional style steel door featuring a 3-layer construction, polyurethane insulation, with a heavy-duty vinyl exterior. Choose from 2 door panel designs, 5 window options, and 4 standard colors. Durafirm costs between $2,000 and $3,500.
If you’re looking for a traditional style maintenance-free garage door with the authentic appearance of wood, consider the Impression Fiberglass profile. This is a 3-layer, polyurethane insulated, steel door with a molded fiberglass, wood-grain textured exterior, available in 4 door panel designs. Select from 15 window options and 10 standard colors that include wood-tone finishes, Prices range from $3,000-$4,500.
The Traditional Wood profile is a 1-layer, all wood door, available in 10 door panel designs, with a variety of wood-framed window options. The door is available primed or unfinished, in stain or paint-grade woods. Prices run from $2,000 to about $3,500.
Modern Style Garage Doors
The C.H.I. Contemporary Collection includes 3 modern style, steel garage doors under the Planks, Sterling, and Skyline Flush profiles. Planks feature the look of thin, horizontal wood planks in insulated steel, available in 9 standard solid colors, or in 7 wood-tone finishes including Driftwood, Cedar, Natural, and Carbon Oak. Short or long rectangular windows can be installed in various places on the door. Prices for the Planks profile run from $1,500 to $3,000.
Sterling is an insulated steel door featuring a contemporary, minimalist look. The door features wide, horizontal sections with the option to use frameless, tinted glass in one, or more, of the sections. The Sterling is available in a wide range of standard and custom colors including metal-tones like Galvalume, Western Rust, Aged Copper, and Copper Penny. There are also many traditional colors like black, white, grays, greens, and reds. Prices range from $1,800 to $3,200.
Skyline Flush is a 1, 2, or 3-layer steel garage door that features 4 wide, horizontal panels. Windows are available in oversized, long, or short rectangles or sized to run the width of the door. Skyline Flush comes in the same color choice as Sterling with an additional choice of 7 wood-tone finishes. Prices start at $1,200 and run up to about $4,500.
Full-View Aluminum is another of C.H.I.’s modern style garage doors and is constructed from heavy-duty aluminum with large panels of glass. You can choose the aluminum frame with, or without insulation, in 10 standard colors plus 188 powder-coated custom colors. Standard glass choices include plain, frosted, tinted, and obscure but there are also custom glass choices, or replace some of the glass panels with solid and specialty options. Prices range from $3,500 to over $6,500.
The Overhead Door Company
The Overhead door offers 4 modern garage door profiles. The Thermacore and Impression Fiberglass have been reviewed above. The Thermacore is a 3-layer steel door, and the Impression Fiberglass is a 3-layer steel door with a fiberglass exterior. Both doors are available in door panel designs and window choices that provide a modern style.
The Modern Aluminum profile is constructed with a durable aluminum frame in either a narrow or a wide frame with glass panels. The glass panels are available in laminated white, tempered, tints, obscure, or non-glass options like Plexiglas or polycarbonate. Modern Aluminum pricing starts at about $3,200 and runs up to $6,000.
The Envy is Overhead Door’s ultra-modern door profile and is constructed with glass panels and an aluminum frame on the interior only, giving the exterior of the door a completely frameless appearance. Choose from a number of glass options including mirrored bronze or gray, opaque white or black, and translucent black. Prices range from $4,500 to $6,500.
Overhead Door Corporation vs C.H.I. Garage Door Warranties
Overhead Door provides a 15 year, a 20 year, or a Limited Lifetime warranty on most of their garage doors with parts at 3-year warranties. The aluminum and glass doors, as well as the wood doors hold 1-year warranties.
C.H.I. provides a Limited Lifetime warranty on most of their garage doors sections, including the Full-View Aluminum profile. Composite overlay material holds a 3-year warranty, springs include 3-year warranties and hardware holds 6-year warranties.
Visit the CHI Garage Doors and the Overhead Garage Door websites for detailed warranty information for all of the garage door profiles.
C.H.I. vs Overhead Door Reviews
C.H.I. receives good reviews for providing high-quality, both in materials, and in the construction of their doors. The doors often exceed industry standards when it comes to strength and durability. They currently appear to be experiencing long delivery times and quality issues which include poor packaging causing damage during shipping. These current problems may be caused by the pandemic and supply chain issues.
Garage door dealers indicate the C.H.I. is very committed to supporting their dealers, so it may be best, currently, to purchase a C.H.I. garage door from a C.H.I. dealer.
The Overhead Door website provides a variety of very positive reviews from customers. In general, they are known for excellent, high-quality products.
The Overhead Door only sells their garage doors through dealers. The company receives a 4-star rating but there are some negative reviews that are specific to individual dealers, rather than the company as a whole. Researching Overhead Door dealers before calling one is a good idea.