Amarr and Clopay are known for being two of the top garage door manufacturers in the industry offering well-made, reliable products, that millions of homeowners are happy with. They both make garage doors to fit your budget, your home’s architectural style and your security needs. These range from good-quality low-price steel doors, beautifully designed midrange choices and high-end premium garage doors. Below you’ll find Clopay vs Amarr garage door reviews comparing a number of factors including materials, styles, features, and costs to help guide you in finding a garage door that will best meet your needs and budget.
History
Both Amarr and Clopay have been in the residential garage door business for many years, Amarr for 70 years and Clopay for almost 60 years.
Amarr was established in 1951 and has become one of the world’s leading brands in the residential and commercial garage door markets when compared with other garage door brands. Their doors are manufactured at plants in Kansas and North Carolina.
While Clopay’s history begins in 1859 as a paper wholesaler, they entered the garage door business in 1964. As of 2019 they are the largest manufacturer of overhead garage doors in North America. Clopay garage doors are made at facilities in Ohio, Wisconsin, and Washington.
Clopay vs Amarr Garage Door Options
These sections compare Clopay vs Amarr garage doors in key areas that will inform your buying decision.
| Comparison Amarr vs Clopay Garage Doors By Style | |||||
| Amarr | Clopay | ||||
| Traditional | |||||
| Lincoln, Olympus, Heritage | Gallery, Bridgeport, Classic Steel, Classic Wood | ||||
| Profiles | 3 | 4 | |||
| Materials | Steel | Steel | |||
| Construction | 1, 2, 3-Layers | 1, 2, 3-Layers | |||
| R-Values | Up to 19.4 | Up to 18.4 | |||
| Price Range | $800 – $2,600 | $500 – $3,500 | |||
| Carriage House | |||||
| Hillcrest, Designer’s Choice, Carriage Court, Heritage Carriage Court, Classica | Canyon Ridge Carriage House, Coachman, Grand Harbor, Reserve Wood Limited Edition, | ||||
| Profiles | 5 | 5 | |||
| Materials | Steel | 3 Steel, 1 Wood | |||
| Construction | 1, 2, 3, 4-Layers | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5-Layers | |||
| R-Values | Up to 19.4 | Up to 20.4 | |||
| Price Range | $1,000 – $5,000 | $2,500 – $6,500 | |||
| Modern | |||||
| Horizon, Vista, Classica Flush, Classica Full View | Canyon Ridge Modern, Modern Steel, Reserve Wood Modern, Avante | ||||
| Profiles | 4 | 4 | |||
| Materials | 2 Aluminum, 2 Steel | 1 Aluminum, 2 Steel, 1 Wood | |||
| Construction | 1, and 3-Layers | 1, 2, 3, 4-Layers | |||
| R-Values | Up to 13.35 | Up to 20.4 | |||
| Price Range | $2,900 – $8,500 | $800 – $6,500 | |||
| Coastal/Plantation | |||||
| Canyon Ridge Louver | |||||
| Profiles | 0 | 1 | |||
| Materials | Steel | ||||
| Construction | 5-Layer | ||||
| R-Values | 20.4 | ||||
| Price Range | $4,500 – $6,500 | ||||
| Custom Wood | |||||
| Amarr By Design | Reserve Wood Custom | ||||
| Profiles | 1 | 1 | |||
| Materials | Wood | Wood | |||
| Construction | 3 or 4-Layers | 4-Layers | |||
| R-Values | 9 | 5.9 | |||
| Price Range | $3,500 and Up | $3,500 and Up | |||
| Construction | 3 or 4-Layers | 4-Layers | |||
| R-Values | 9 | 5.9 | |||
| Price Range | $3,500 and Up | $3,500 and Up | |||
Materials – Steel, Aluminum, Wood and Composite
Amarr and Clopay both make garage doors in steel, aluminum, and wood. Amarr offers one door and Clopay manufactures several doors with an exterior layer of faux wood composite which has been molded with actual wood grain textures.
Advantage: Clopay
Styles
The brands produce garage doors in traditional, carriage house, modern, and wood styles. Clopay also makes a door in a coastal style with the look of plantation shutters.
Advantage: Clopay
Door Layers
Amarr and Clopay construct their garage doors in layers. A door described as being 1-layer means that the door is not insulated and includes only a single material, like steel or wood. A 2-layer door typically includes the door material plus a layer of insulation which is backed by a material like vinyl. A 3-layer door includes the door material, a layer of insulation, and a layer of the same material as the exterior, such as steel, which covers the insulation.
4 and 5-layer doors will include the above 3 layers plus overlay materials, usually a faux wood composite overlay on a 4-layer door with an additional composite cladding on a 5-layer door.
Advantage: Even
Insulation
Both Amarr and Clopay provide insulation options on many of their doors. The options include a choice of either polystyrene or polyurethane at a thickness of 1-3/8” or 2”. Clopay notes that they use proprietary polyurethane foam that is injected into the door expanding to fill the entire interior providing strength and a better insulated door, but it also increases costs.
Advantage: Clopay
Mosaic Windows
Amarr offers an interesting window design feature on a number of their doors. The Mosaic Windows option allows you to place windows in unconventional positions on the door. For instance, you can choose to stack 4 long, narrow windows down one, or both, sides of the door, or place four windows centered in the middle of the door.
Advantage: Amarr
Garage Door Colors
Amarr offers many standard colors including white, almond, brown, and black, plus more than 800 Sherwin-Williams colors through their Color Zone option. Color Zone is available on all steel doors and allows homeowners to match the garage door to exterior features on their home like shutters and front doors.
Clopay also gives you a number of standard color choices including white, sandstone, bronze, brown, green, and gray, plus a custom color option, Color Blast which also uses Sherwin-Williams paint colors and is available on most of their steel doors.
Advantage: Amarr
Ultra-Grain Wood-Look Paint Finish
Clopay’s Ultra-Grain finish is a durable paint finish that creates a natural-looking wood grain on the door. It’s specifically designed for steel doors where the appearance of stained wood is desired, but with the low maintenance of steel.
Colors include Walnut and Cherry in dark and medium tones. Window frames, grilles, and inserts are all color matched to coordinate with the Ultra-Grain finish. Amarr doesn’t produce anything quite like this.
Advantage: Clopay
Amarr vs Clopay Garage Door Costs
All of the prices are based on standard garage door sizes including 1-car and 2-car garage doors.
Amarr garage door prices range from about $1,000, for one of their most affordable steel doors, to more than $5,000 for a multi-layer steel and composite door, to as high as $8,500 for their custom wood garage doors.
Clopay prices start at about $500 for their single-layer steel door, without windows to $6,500 for a 5-layer steel and composite door or an aluminum and glass door, and more, for a fully custom wood door.
While Clopay does have a few doors in the budget category, overall, they feature more premium doors than Amarr.
| Comparison Amarr vs Clopay Garage Doors by Prices | ||||||
| Profile | Style | Material | Layers | R-Value | Price | Price Category |
| Amarr | ||||||
| Lincoln | Traditional | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | 6.64-9.05 | $850 – $2,200 | Budget |
| Heritage | Traditional | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | 6.64-9.05 | $1,500 – $2,500 | Budget |
| Hillcrest | Carriage House | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | 6.64-9.05 | $1,000 – $2,400 | Budget |
| Heritage Carriage Court | Carriage House | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | 6.64-9.05 | $1,500 – $2,500 | Budget |
| Olympus | Traditional | Steel | 3 | 13.35-19.4 | $1,700 – $2,600 | Mid-Range |
| Designer’s Choice | Carriage House | Steel | 3 | 13.35-19.40 | $2,000 – $3,200 | Mid-Range |
| Classica | Carriage House | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | 6.64-13.35 | $1,550 – $3,500 | Mid-Range |
| Classica Flush | Modern | Steel | 3 | 13.35 | $2,900 – $3,500 | Mid-Range |
| Classica Full View | Modern | Steel | 3 | 13.35 | $2,900 – $3,500 | Mid-Range |
| Carriage Court | Carriage House | Steel | 4 | 6.48 | $3,500 – $5,000 | Premium |
| Vista | Modern | Aluminum | 1 | N/A | $4,800 – $8.500 | Premium |
| Horizon | Modern | Aluminum | 1 | N/A | $5,500 – $8,000 | Premium |
| Amarr By Design | Custom | Wood | 3 | 9.0 | $4,500 + | Premium |
| Clopay | ||||||
| Classic Steel | Traditional | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | 18.4 | $500 – $2,500 | Budget |
| Modern Steel | Modern | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | Up to 18.4 | $800 – $3,000 | Budget |
| Gallery Steel | Traditional | Steel | 1, 2, or 3 | Up to 18.4 | $1,000 – $3,500 |
Budget to Mid-Range
|
| Classic Wood | Traditional | Wood | 1 | N/A | $1,500 – $3,500 |
Budget to Mid-Range
|
| Grand Harbor | Carriage House | Steel | 2 or 3 | 6.3 | $2,500 – $4,500 | Mid-Range |
| Bridgeport Steel | Traditional | Steel | 3 | 12.9-18.4 | $2,700 – $3,200 | Mid-Range |
| Coachman | Carriage House | Steel | 4 | 6.5-18.4 | $3,000 – $4,500 | Mid-Range |
| Reserve Wood Semi-Custom | Carriage House | Wood | 2 | N/A | $2,500 – $4,000 | Mid-Range |
| Canyon Ridge Carriage House | Carriage House | Steel | 4 or 5 | 18.4-20.4 | $3,500 – $6,500 | Premium |
| Canyon Ridge Modern | Modern | Steel | 4 | 6.3-20.4 | $3,500 – $6,000 | Premium |
| Canyon Ridge Louver | Coastal | Steel | 5 | 20.4 | $4,500 – $6,500 | Premium |
| Avante | Modern | Aluminum | 1 | N/A | $4,000 – $6,500 | Premium |
| Reserve Wood Limited Edition | Carriage House | Wood | 4 or 5 | 5.9 | $3,000 – $6,000 | Premium |
| Reserve Wood Modern | Modern | Wood | 4 | 5.9 | $3,000 – $6,000 | Premium |
| Reserve Wood Custom | Custom | Wood | Custom | Custom | $3,500 + | Premium |
Clopay vs Amarr Garage Door Collections
Amarr offers 13 garage door choices and Clopay offers 15 choices. Amarr groups their garage doors by style, in four collections – Traditional, Carriage House, Modern, and Wood, while Clopay lists their doors individually.
Amarr vs Clopay Garage Door Collections & Reviews
Here we look at each manufacturer’s garage door profiles or styles and what they offer including price ranges.
As noted, costs are included in the reviews too, so you can find options for your budget.
Traditional Style Garage Doors
These doors offer classic good looks including 6-panel styles and other common designs.
Amarr
Amarr features 3 traditional style garage doors – Lincoln, Olympus, and Heritage. These doors are all stamped steel with long, short or flush panels and available in 1, 2, or 3-layers with a choice of insulation.
Prices range from about $850 for a non-insulated door without windows to $2,600 for a 3-layer door with windows.
Clopay
Clopay also offers 4 traditional style doors – Gallery Steel, Bridgeport Steel, Classic Steel, and Classic Wood. These doors are available with long or short, raised, recessed, or grooved panels, depending on the profile. The doors are available in 1, 2, or 3-layers with a choice of insulation.
Prices range from $500 for a steel non-insulated door without windows to $3,500 for a steel 3-layer door or the Classic Wood profile with windows and custom paint.
Carriage House Style Garage Doors
This super-vintage look offered by carriage house style garage doors is popular for upscale homes with traditional architecture.
Amarr
Amarr offers 5 carriage house garage door choices – Hillcrest, Designer’s Choice, Carriage Court, Heritage Carriage Court, and Classica.
Hillcrest, Designer’s Choice, and Heritage Carriage Court are all stamped steel doors in raised, recessed, or beaded panels with 1, 2, or 3-layer construction. These doors are Amarr’s most affordable carriage house style doors.
Classica features a 3-layer steel door stamped to provide the appearance of a carriage house door with wood trim.
Carriage Court is Amarr’s premium choice in the carriage house profile and features 3-layer construction with an additional layer of 5/8” thick faux-wood composite creating the appearance of a multi-layer door. Carriage Court is available in 14 door styles.
Prices range from $1,000 for a door without insulation or windows to $5,000 for the Carriage Court profile with insulation and windows.
Clopay
Clopay manufactures 5 carriage house style garage doors – Canyon Ridge Carriage House, Coachman, Grand Harbor, Reserve Wood Limited Edition, and Reserve Wood Semi-Custom.
The Canyon Ridge Carriage House profile is one of Clopay’s most expensive doors with 4 or 5-layers including 2 layers of steel, insulation, and composite construction. The 5-layer door includes composite cladding and overlay, and the 4-layer door includes only the composite overlay. Both are available in 14 door styles and many window choices.
Coachman is also a 4-layer steel door with a composite overlay and is available in a solid or two-tone color scheme.
Grand Harbor includes a 1 or 2-layer steel construction with composite overlay and is Clopay’s most affordable carriage house door option.
Reserve Wood Limited Edition and Reserve Wood Semi-Custom are Clopay’s all wood carriage house doors. The Semi-Custom profile is constructed of 2 layers, a front and back layer of wood and Limited Edition is constructed with 4 or 5 layers, with or without insulation.
Costs run between $2,500 for Grand Harbor in 1-layer and without windows to $6,500 for either the Canyon Ridge or Reserve Wood 5-layer doors.
Modern Style Garage Doors
These doors look best on today’s contemporary home designs.
Amarr
Amarr features 4 modern style doors – Vista, Horizon, Classica Flush, and Classica Full View.
Vista and Horizon are both made of a non-insulated aluminum frame filled with large windows. Vista features windows that are half the width of a standard door and Horizon features long horizontal windows that are the full width of a standard garage door.
Classica Flush and Classica Full View are both 3-layer steel doors with 3 wide flush panels. Classica Flush features 2 large windows at the top of the door and Classica Full View has 6 large windows, 2 across and 3 deep, covering the door. Glass options include clear, obscure, tinted, and thermal.
Prices range from $2,900 to $8,500 depending on profile, glass, and finish choices.
Clopay
Clopay’s modern style garage door choices include Canyon Ridge Modern, Modern Steel, Reserve Wood Modern, and Avante.
Canyon Ridge Modern is a 4-layer steel door with a composite overlay and Modern Steel is available with 1, 2, or 3 layers, without the composite overlay. Reserve Wood Modern is a 4-layer insulated, all wood door. These doors are available with a variety of door and window options.
The Avante is a non-insulated aluminum frame door with 6 large rectangular windows, 2 across and 4 down, covering the door. The door is available in 2 styles of frames and many glass options including clear, tinted, mirrored, and obscure, as well as with acrylic and aluminum inserts.
Prices range from $800 for a non-insulated Modern Steel profile to $6,500 for the other 3 profiles.
Custom Wood Doors
When it has to be authentic, consider a wood door – if it is in the budget. Just keep in mind that wood requires more maintenance than metal and composite doors.
Amarr
Amarr’s Amarr by Design lets you choose from 10 wood carriage house style wood doors or you can custom design your own door wood door. The doors are available in Incense Cedar, Vertical Grain Cedar, Red Grandis, and Mahogany for staining or painting.
Clopay
Clopay’s Reserve Wood Custom is their custom wood door constructed in 4 layers, with or without insulation. Choose from Clopay’s door, window, and wood choices or design it yourself.
Prices for both Amarr and Clopay custom wood doors are $3,500 and above.
Coastal or Plantation Shutter Style Door
This is the unique style mentioned above that is produced only by Clopay.
Clopay
Clopay makes a louvered style door called Canyon Ridge Louver which is a 5-layer, steel door, with faux-wood composite cladding and overlay creating the louvers. Choose from 12 door designs and multiple window options.
The cost for Canyon Ridge Louver is between $4,500 and $6,500.
Amarr vs Clopay Garage Door Warranties
Amarr offers one of the best warranties in the industry with Lifetime Warranties on most of their garage doors, paint finishes, sections, hardware, and springs. A couple of the Hillcrest and Lincoln models have a 25-year warranty on paint finishes and a 2-year warranty on sections, hardware, and springs. Both the Horizon and Vista doors offer 5-year warranties on paint, parts, and windows.
Clopay offers Limited lifetime Warranties with 10 years on standard paint and 5 years on custom paint. Materials, workmanship, hardware, and springs are all 1-year warranties. Clopay also offers a 1-year warranty on installation for all doors installed by a Clopay Authorized Dealer.
The obvious advantage here goes to Amarr.
Clopay vs Amarr Reviews – What are Others Saying?
Clopay seems to be a favorite with home remodeling companies and garage door dealers. They both give Clopay positive reviews for selection and quality. Clopay garage doors won Remodeling Magazine’s Brand Leader award in 2019 recognizing it as the garage door brand remodeling professionals use most frequently. More recently, Clopay was awarded a place on the Pro Builder: Top 100 Products of 2021 list.
Reviews also indicate that Clopay offers a better selection of high-quality mid-range and premium doors than Amarr while Amarr offers a better selection of low and mid-priced garage doors.
Customer reviews, both online and on the Clopay website, are generally positive with most negative comments pertaining to Clopay doors purchased through Home Depot. There are negative reviews about these doors arriving damaged and customers being unable to get replacements.
If you’re planning to purchase a Clopay door, consider going through an authorized Clopay dealer.
Online customer reviews for Amarr indicate that most customers are completely satisfied with their garage door. The unhappy customers primarily have had issues with charges for replacement parts. The warranty covers the parts but usually not the cost to install the new part.
*Currently, both companies are experiencing delivery delays due to supply chain issues.
